PODCAST

Cousins on Crime

Cousins, Alayna and Candace, discuss the wildest true crime cases of all time.

true crime documentary

All Episodes

52:24

49: The Mysterious Disappearance of Robert Hoagland

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/05/03

In the Summer of 2013, a loving husband and devoted father of three mysteriously vanished in Newtown, Connecticut. After nearly 10 years of speculation, confusion, and questions, Robert Hoagland's family would learn the shocking truth about what really happened to him and it was more painful than they could have ever imagined. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

26:42

48: A Crime of Opportunity: The Senseless Murder of...

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/04/26

Marty Etchemendy parted way with his friends after an ordinary night out with the boys. But when Marty couldn't remember when he parked his truck, he could have never known that accepting a ride from some good Samaritans would cost him his life. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

41:33

47: The Devastating Murder of Robert Cantor

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/04/19

In the early morning hours of March 7, 2011, first responders rushed to the scene of a home fully engulfed in flames. Once the fire was out, firefighters made entry and found one victim, but no one could have imagined the horrifying truth behind his death. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by AleXZavesa Sources: https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/crime/2023/01/20/teaneck-nj-love-triangle-murder-trial-set-to-begin-may/69818171007/ “Murder Decoded”-

44:26

46: The Murder of Lauren Giddings

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/04/12

Lauren was a bright, recent law school graduate with her whole life ahead of her. Preparing to take the next step and study for her bar exam, her life was cut short by a deranged and deviant loner. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

46:35

45: Cold Case Solved: Carol Sue Klaber

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/04/05

In early March of 2023, the Klaber family (and the true crime community!) got some exciting news in the 1976 of the Murder of sixteen-year-old Carol Sue Klaber. The nearly fifty-year-old case has been solved!

46:11

44: The Life and Death of Jesus

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/29

We’re taking it waaaaaay back in this episode. You may or may not have heard the story of the life and death of Jesus, so here it goes. A child was born to a young, unwed mother and grew up to lead a following of people who believed he was the son of God. But a Roman high priest would condemn him to death for threatening to overthrow his power. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by AleXZavesa Sources: The

53:37

44: The Life and Death of Jesus

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/29

39:58

43: The Cold-Hearted Murder of Tequila Suter

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/22

Mounds of snow covered the ground and tension filled the air one bitter cold night in New York, back in 2015. Tequila Suter was a young woman on a mission to spread love and light to all those who crossed her path. But a wolf in sheep's clothing would enter her life, leading her down a path of his own... a dead end.

22:14

42: Lady in Lake Worth: Elizabeth Pule Arellano

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/15

Mother of four, Elizabeth Arellano, was in the middle of a divorce and looking for a fresh start. When her mother found her abandoned car one morning, the family was thrust into a nightmare they could never imagine. But an unsuspecting fisherman, who was in the right place at the right time, would help authorities solve a case that may have gone cold. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by AleXZavesa

39:27

41: The Crossbow Cannibal: Stephen Griffiths

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/08

For years, a monster walked the streets of Bradford in West Yorkshire, England before committing the most violent, heinous murders the area had ever seen. Police would soon realize that they stopped an overly ambitious serial killer just in time. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

30:23

40: Mississippi Murderer: Phillip Walker

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/03/01

A wife and mother of two was found murdered in her home one evening in Enterprise, Mississippi. An unlikely suspect confessed to the murder and would serve little time before being released back into the population. Would he stay on the straight and narrow? Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by AleXZavesa Sources: www.newspapers.com

42:39

39: Serial Killer: James Koedatich

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/02/22

It was a cool October day in 1982. The cheerleaders at Parsippany High School, in New Jersey, were gearing up for one of the biggest games of the year and looking forward to fall break. But all of that excitement would come crashing down when one of their own was found dead in a rural area on Thanksgiving day. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

37:45

38: The Stabbing Deaths of George and Catherine Peacock

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/02/15

When an elderly gentleman didn't show up for work, his coworkers grew very concerned. Finding George Peacock, and his wife, dead in their home, would reveal clues that would lead investigators to believe the killer may be closer than they think. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

51:11

37: Where in the World is Lord Lucan?

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/02/08

A cold November night would end the life of an unsuspecting young woman and would leave police struggling to solve a mystery that would span decades. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

50:02

36: The Murder of Shirley Duguay

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/02/01

A petite mother of five, was reported missing when she hadn't been heard from in days. The search and investigation into the disappearance of Shirley Duguay would lead forensic analysts down a road they never expected and a new scientific breakthrough would set a precedent for cases to come.

51:58

35: The Brutal Murder of Tynesha Stewart

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/01/25

Tynesha Stewart was a bright and confident college student, determined to make an impression on the world. She could have never known that the legacy she'd leave behind would be a cautionary tale of the dangers of domestic violence. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

41:38

34: The Pretty Killer of the South: Winona Green

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/01/18

In the early 1900's Winona Green was ruthlessly driven by greed. At just 23 years old, she was sentenced to life in prison for a double homicide, but instead of serving her sentence, she went on to kill again and again. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

47:23

33: Serial Killer Pee Wee Gaskins: Part Three

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/01/11

He's been dubbed "The Meanest Man in America. South Carolina's most prolific serial killer, Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins, was driven by hate and fearlessness. He terrorized the south, escalating from petty crimes to mass murder. In Part Three, we'll wrap up this story (because we all need to move on with our lives!) by talking about Pee Wee's convictions, final kill, and punishment. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

51:02

32: Serial Killer Pee Wee Gaskins: Part Two

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/01/06

He's been dubbed "The Meanest Man in America. South Carolina's most prolific serial killer, Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins, was driven by hate and fearlessness. He terrorized the south, escalating from petty crimes to mass murder. In Part Two, get into Pee Wee's prison stays, prison breaks, and the beginning of his murder spree. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

39:32

31: Serial Killer Pee Wee Gaskins: Part One

Cousins on Crime ·

2023/01/04

He's been dubbed "The Meanest Man in America. South Carolina's most prolific serial killer, Donald Henry "Pee Wee" Gaskins, was driven by hate and fearlessness. He terrorized the south, escalating from petty crimes to mass murder. In Part One, we dissect Pee Wee's childhood and adolescence and learn how his tragic upbringing set the tone for the darkness that would follow. Instagram: @CousinsonCrimePodcast Email: CousinsonCrime@gmail.com Theme Music by

170 results

Cousins on Crime

All Episodes

Similar Podcasts

Australian True Crime

Bravecasting

True Crime Podcast 2025 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast

True Crime Podcast 2025

Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast

Jay Nicoll

The Conspiracy Files

Bloody FM

Crime at Bedtime

Jack Laurence