PODCAST

Reaper Tales

Montana Leach and Samantha Hays

A weekly podcast about everything from true crime to bigfoot

true crime

All Episodes

57:20

Episode 48: The Bunny Man

Reaper Tales ·

2023/04/07

Happy Easter! Or whatever you celebrate. This week Montana tells Samantha about creepy legend of the Bunny man. We don't think you'd want this bunny leaving eggs at your house.

66:07

Episode 47: Get outta my Swamp

Reaper Tales ·

2023/03/31

This week the Gals tell each other about a local swamp cryptid. If you listen carefully you'll hear Montana's soul leave her body mid episode when an intruder enters her home. This episode is smelly and slimy friends so be prepared.

52:33

Episode 46: A Twofer

Reaper Tales ·

2023/03/24

This week Montana tells Samantha about two different murder young women in North Carolina. First case is about a young murdered 15 year old, Donna Emmel. The second case covers the brutal murder (in public) of Suellen

76:16

Episode 45: Psych'd episode

Reaper Tales ·

2023/03/17

This week the gals tell each other about different psychics from their areas. One is a truly fascinating story of a well known psychic who had many predictions come true and the other.... Isn't Buckle up listeners, this one gets a bit HAIRY. Resources:Legends and Lore of Birmingham & Central Alabama, by Beverly CriderEearie Alabama, Chilling Tales from the Heart of Dixie, by Alan

48:36

Episode 44: The Citronelle Homicides

Reaper Tales ·

2023/03/10

This week Samantha tells Montana about one of the worst mass killings in Mobile county history. The story is loaded with hot topics to say the least. This is a case of a clear perpetrator, but the excuses/explanations provided are sure to cause all kinds of feelings... they sure did for the

63:23

Episode 43: Places where stuff happened

Reaper Tales ·

2023/03/03

This week the gals tell each other about odd and spooky occurrences from their area. Some how aliens and Mary Magdalena play a roll in all of this. Not to mention a ghost trying to get a very weird leg workout in the afterlife.

55:15

Episode 42: Payne Road... Sort of

Reaper Tales ·

2023/02/24

The Gals are back after a week off from moving and exploding bladders! This week Montana tells Samantha about the legends surrounding Payne road.... or is it Edwards road? Who knows

76:24

Episode 41: Daniel Lee Siebert

Reaper Tales ·

2023/02/10

This week, Samantha tells Montana about Daniel Lee Siebert. If you need a plushie to help get you through this episode, we won’t judge. Montana had her happy/angry octopus handy to help her cope during this recording.

69:25

Episode 40: Valentines Tragedies

Reaper Tales ·

2023/02/03

This week the Gals tell each other about a different unsolved valentines tragedy. While both cases have a great suspect, there is no evidence to convict in either. This wasn't planned on our part.

68:06

Episode 39: The Murder of Judy Smith

Reaper Tales ·

2023/01/27

This week Montana tells the bizarre story of the murder of Judy Smith. Boston residents Judy and her husband Jeffrey travel to Philadelphia for a work conference Jeffrey is attending. On their first day there Judy disappears while out sight seeing around the city. Only to show up months later hundreds of miles away murdered in a state park.

74:09

Episode 38: Another Black Widow

Reaper Tales ·

2023/01/20

This week, Samantha tell Montana about Audrey Marie Hilley: a woman that seemed to love drama so much that she created her own real life soap opera! Get ready folks, this one is EXTRA. Resources:https://thecrimewire.com/true-crime/audrey-marie-hilleyhttps://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Marie_Hilleyhttps://murderpedia.org/female.H/h/hilley-audrey.htmhttp://maamodt.asp.radford.edu/Psyc%20405/serial%20killers/Hilley,%20Marie%20_2012_.pdf

81:54

Episode 37: New Year's resolutions

Reaper Tales ·

2023/01/13

This week the Reaper Gals bring you a duel episode. Montana tells Samantha about the murder of Meredith Hope Emerson. While Samantha tells Montana a curated list of gym horror stories. Resources:

49:25

Episode 36: The Murder of Rhonda Hinson

Reaper Tales ·

2023/01/06

This week Montana tells Samantha about the tragic unsolved murder of Rhonda Hinson. This episode is full of contradicting statements, an odd crime scene, and a passionate reporter.

1:34

This is not an episode 1: We're taking the week off

Reaper Tales ·

2022/12/30

The Reaper Gals are taking this week off.

80:31

Episode 35: Something Christmas-y, Probably

Reaper Tales ·

2022/12/23

This week Samantha tells Montana several different disturbing stories centered around the holidays in Alabama. The reaper gals apologizes for the delayed upload this week. Better late than never

44:45

Episode 34: The Lawson Family Murders

Reaper Tales ·

2022/12/16

On Christmas day in 1929, the Lawson family were preparing to celebrate a quiet holiday at home, but the joy of the holiday was short living when 7 of the 8 family members end up dead. Grab your eggnog listeners this a gruesome

76:55

Episode 33: Holiday Haunts Pt 1

Reaper Tales ·

2022/12/09

This week the gals tell each other a different hauntingly holiday-ish tales. Look, I'm doing my best on these descriptions.

76:03

Episode 32: Andrew Reid Lackey

Reaper Tales ·

2022/12/02

This week, Samantha tells Montana about Andrew Reid Lackey, the Halloween Killer. It’s a sad story from start to finish and it’s sure to bring up some mixed feelings on several topics….it certainly did for the gals.

56:59

Episode 31: The Durham and Fleming family murders

Reaper Tales ·

2022/11/25

This week Montana tells Samantha a story she has already heard, but that you dear listeners haven't. A story that marked a traitorous day in Reaper Tales history as the day that shall not be named. This weeks episode is the horrendous story of two separate murders that have a surprising tie to each other in the end.

51:52

Episode 30: Hauntings

Reaper Tales ·

2022/11/18

This week both of the gals bring you a different haunting story. Buckle up Reaper friends this one gets spooky.Resources:https://www.newspapers.com/clip/50445160/surprise-survivor/https://www.newspapers.com/clip/50442919/public-invited-to-inspect-new-mayfair/https://queencityghosts.com/the-haunted-dunhill-hotel/https://twosistersabroad.com/review-and-ghost-stories-from-the-dunhill-hotel-in-charlotte/

131 results

Reaper Tales

All Episodes

Similar Podcasts

Australian True Crime

Bravecasting

True Crime Podcast 2025 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast

True Crime Podcast 2025

Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast

Jay Nicoll

The Conspiracy Files

Bloody FM

Crime at Bedtime

Jack Laurence