x

75% of people globally want unbiased news (Pew Research) but are concerned they're not getting that.

Get balanced coverage with Symby. See how stories are covered across diverse outlets and spot when one side covers a story the other skips.

PODCAST

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!

Megan Owens & Mindy Johnson

🎙️ Welcome to Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder!We’re your hosts, Megan and Mindy — sisters, storytellers, retired educators, and lifelong lovers of true crime and all things mysterious. From chilling cold cases to strange small-town secrets, we’ll dig deep into the stories that keep you up at night… especially the ones hiding right here in the heart of Missouri.Our podcast launched Fall 2025, and we are excited to take you on a journey through the twists, turns, and mayhem that make our

true crime documentary

All Episodes

24:21

President for a Day - David Rice Atchison - Platte...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/02/16

Missouri Mayhem - In this episode, we explore the fascinating myth surrounding Missouri politician David Rice Atchison, who allegedly served as U.S. President for a single day in 1849. We dive into the historical context of mid-19th century America, the political chaos of 1849, and the truth behind this intriguing legend—plus, what it reveals about history, myth, and power. EXPANDED REFERENCESU.S. Senate Historical Office – No, David Rice Atchison Was Not President for a DaySnopes – Was David Rice

en

36:41

The Davis Tutt & Wild Bill Hickok Duel - Springfield,...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/02/09

Missouri Mayhem - Join us as we explore the extraordinary life of Wild Bill Hickok — from his early days in Illinois to legendary gunfights in Kansas and South Dakota. Discover the stories behind his rise to fame, his notorious duel, and the mysterious circumstances of his death.Primary Sources & Historical RecordsGreene County Circuit Court Records: The original 1865 court proceedings for State of Missouri vs. William Hickok and the coroner's inquest report for Davis Tutt are preserved at the

en

37:10

The Tragic Murder of 9 Year Old Elizabeth Olten - St....

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/02/02

This Missouri Mayhem episode delves into one of the most disturbing and perplexing crimes in recent Missouri history, focusing on the murder of Elizabeth Olten in October of 2009. The discussion highlights the intersection of violence and mental health, with Alyssa Bustamante ultimately pleading guilty to second-degree murder. The episode emphasizes the importance of addressing mental health crises and provides resources such as the 988 crisis lifeline and BetterHelp.com for those in need. Listeners

en

40:51

The Package Killer: Gary Muelhberg 1990-1993 - St,...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/01/26

On this episode of Missouri Mayhem, Mindy and Megan delve into the chilling story of Gary Randall Muehlberg, known as The Package Killer. The episode explores Muehlberg's life, his criminal history, and the series of murders he committed in the early 1990s. The hosts discuss the impact of his actions on the victims' families and the eventual breakthrough in the case due to DNA evidence.KeywordsGary Randall Muehlberg, package killer, serial killer, DNA evidence, Missouri MayhemReference & Summary

en

25:31

The Kidnapping & Rescue of Shawn Hornbeck & Ben Ownby...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/01/21

This Missouri Mayhem episode delves into the extraordinary recovery of Sean Hornbeck and Ben Ownby, exploring the events leading up to their rescue and the impact on law enforcement practices. The discussion highlights the emotional and psychological aspects of the case, including trauma bonding and the changes in handling missing child cases.REFERENCE LIST Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2007). FBI Press Conference on the Recovery of Shawn Hornbeck and Ben Ownby.The St. Louis Post-Dispatch

en

63:04

Ben Renick - The Missouri Snake Breeder Murder - New...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/01/19

This episode of "Missouri Mayhem" delves into the mysterious and tragic story of Ben Renick, a renowned snake breeder, who was found dead in his facility in 2017. The narrative unfolds with the investigation into his murder, initially suspected to be a snake attack, but later revealed to be a homicide involving his wife, Lynlee Renick. The episode explores the complexities of their relationship, financial troubles, and Lynlee's alleged involvement in the murder plot, alongside her ex-boyfriend and a

en

38:07

Harry S. Truman - His Life, Home, Museum, & "Ghost" -...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/01/12

In this episode of "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder," hosts Mindy and Megan explore the life and legacy of Harry Truman, the 33rd President of the United States. They delve into his significant contributions, such as the Truman Doctrine, the Marshall Plan, and his role in World War II. The episode also covers personal anecdotes about Truman's life, including his marriage to Bess, their home in Independence, Missouri, and the intriguing stories surrounding his ghostly presence both at his home

en

34:10

The Kansas City Strangler - Lorenzo Gilyard, Jr.

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2026/01/05

This Missouri Mayhem episode delves into the chilling story of Lorenzo Jerome Gilyard Jr., also known as the Kansas City Strangler. It explores his double life, earlier criminal activities, and the eventual breakthrough in the case through DNA evidence. This evidence conclusively linked Gilyard to the murders of six women, leading to his arrest on April 16, 2004, and subsequent charges of 12 counts of first-degree murder. The episode concludes with Gilyard's sentencing to life in prison without

en

31:17

The Steamboats of Missouri - Steamboat Arabia &...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/12/29

In this episode of Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder, hosts Mindy and Megan explore the intriguing history of two steamboats, the Arabia and the Malta, both of which met their fate on the Missouri River. The discussion delves into the cultural and historical significance of these vessels, the dangers of river travel in the 1800s, and the fascinating discoveries made during the excavation of the Arabia. The episode also touches on the ongoing mystery of the Malta and its impact on river navigation

en

32:59

The Pony Express - St. Joseph, Missouri to...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/12/22

This Missouri Mayhem episode provides an overview of the Pony Express, a mail service that operated from April 1860 to October 1861, using relays of young riders on horses to deliver mail across approximately 2000 miles from St. Joseph, Missouri, to Sacramento, California. The service was prompted by California's rapidly growing population and aimed to deliver mail in about 10 days. Despite its speed and innovation, the Pony Express was not a financial success and went bankrupt after 18 months,

en

25:08

Nicholas & Justin Diemel: The Cattle Fraud & Murder...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/12/15

This episode of "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder" delves into the tragic story of Nicholas and Justin Diemel, two brothers from Wisconsin who were victims of a deceitful cattle fraud scheme. The brothers, known for their hard work and integrity, were lured into a business deal with Garland Joseph Nelson, a man with a history of cattle fraud. The episode uncovers the brothers' journey to Missouri to resolve a business dispute, only to face a grim fate at the hands of Nelson. The narrative

en

44:45

The Ryan Ferguson Case - His Conviction &...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/12/08

This episode titled "The Ryan Ferguson Case" from the podcast "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder" delves into the wrongful conviction of Ryan Ferguson for the 2001 murder of sports editor Ken Heitholt in Columbia, Missouri. The hosts, Mindy and Megan, discuss the events leading to Ferguson's conviction, including the confession of Chuck Erickson, who implicated Ferguson. Despite a lack of physical evidence linking Ferguson to the crime, he was convicted based on Erickson's testimony. The episode

en

45:49

Ray and Faye Copeland - The Missouri Serial Killer...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/12/01

This episode delves into the chilling true crime story of Ray and Faye Copeland, Missouri's oldest couple ever sentenced to death. Set in 1989, the narrative unfolds on a quiet farm in Mooresville, Missouri, where the discovery of human remains leads to the unraveling of a complex fraudulent scheme. Ray and Faye exploited drifters and transients, using them in a cattle-buying scam that escalated into serial murder. The episode explores their backgrounds, the execution-style killings, and the

en

34:34

The I-70 Killer Case: The Missouri, Kansas, Indiana,...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/11/24

This episode of "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder" delves into the chilling case of the I-70 killings that started in 1992 with a man who targeted store clerks along the I-70 highway, spanning multiple states. The episode provides a detailed account of the victims, the circumstances of their deaths, and the ongoing mystery surrounding the killer's identity. Despite being featured on various crime shows, the case remains unsolved, with no suspects identified. The hosts emphasize the importance of

en

46:44

The Anti-Freeze Murders: The Poisoning of the Staudte...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/11/17

This episode of "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder" delves into the chilling case of the Staudte family, known as the Antifreeze Murders. The hosts, Megan and Mindy, explore the seemingly ordinary life of the Staudte family in Springfield, Missouri, which hid a dark secret. The episode recounts the deaths of Mark Staudte, his son Sean, and the near-death of his daughter Sarah, all orchestrated by Diane with the help of her daughter Rachel. The narrative unfolds with Diane's confession to poisoning

en

47:17

The Angela Hammond Case - Clinton Missouri Kidnapping...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/11/10

This Missouri Mayhem episode delves into the tragic case of Angela Hammond, who went missing in 1991 from Clinton, Missouri. The hosts discuss Angela's background, her relationship with her fiancé Rob Schaefer, and the events leading up to her abduction. They explore the investigation that followed and the suspects that emerged over the years. Recent developments, including a mysterious letter received by a confidential informant, add a new layer to the case, which remains unsolved after three

en

37:05

The History of Pythian Castle - Springfield Missouri

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/11/05

CORRECTION - SPRINGFIELD POPULATION IS 470,000 (NOT 170,000) - APOLOGIES! This episode of "Missouri Mayhem, Mystery and Murder" takes listeners on a journey through the history of Pythian Castle in Springfield, Missouri. Hosts Megan and Mindy explore the castle's origins as a home for orphans and elderly members of the Knights of Pythias, its transformation into a military facility during World War II, and its current status as a historical landmark and ghost tour destination. The episode weaves

en

49:57

Whitney Gray - The Independence Missouri Road Rage &...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/11/03

In this episode of "Missouri Mayhem: Mystery and Murder," hosts Megan and Mindy delve into the tragic case of Whitney Gray, a young mother whose life was cut short by a road rage incident in Independence, Missouri. The episode explores the events leading up to the incident, the aftermath, and the broader implications of road rage in today's society. Join us as we remember Whitney and discuss the importance of staying calm and safe on the roads.*Follow us at:Patreon -

en

16:43

Mini-Mayhem: Happy Halloween - The Legend of the...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/10/31

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, hosts Mindy and Megan delve into the folklore of the Ozark Mountains, focusing on the mythical creature known as the Snawfus. The creature is described as a large, deer-like animal with pure white fur, wings, and antlers resembling tree branches covered in plum blossoms. It exhales blue smoke and is said to have a mystical presence, often associated with supernatural powers. The creature's legend, rooted in 19th and early 20th-century tales, symbolizes the wild,

en

25:24

Mini-Mayhem: The VooDoo Witch of Missouri - Molly...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! ·

2025/10/30

In this Halloween special of "Missouri Mayhem," hosts Megan and Mindy delve into the chilling legend of Molly Crenshaw, the so-called Missouri Voodoo Witch. The episode explores the folklore surrounding Molly, a freed slave rumored to have practiced witchcraft in St. Charles, Missouri, and the tragic events that led to her demise. The hosts also discuss the real-life Mollie J. Crenshaw, a schoolteacher whose life ended in tragedy, and how her story became intertwined with the legend. This episode is

en

36 results

Similar Podcasts

Australian True Crime

Bravecasting

True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast

True Crime Podcast 2025

Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast

Jay Nicoll

The Conspiracy Files

Bloody FM

Crime at Bedtime

Jack Laurence